2009-2010 Canton Central Catholic (OH) - Keller & Massarelli
From NDCA Wiki
Contents |
Affirmative
1. THE FOOD DELIVERY PROGRAM ON INDIAN RESERVATIONS IS NOT ENOUGH—OVER TWENTY PERCENT OF INDIANS HUNGRY
SPARK 2007
(Dr. Arlene, nutritionist and associate professor at Hunter College, CUNY, Nutrition In Public Health, p 421)
2. DESPITE PROMISES TO THE CONTRARY, THE USDA PROCURES FARM-RAISED BISON FOR THE FOOD DELIVERY PROGRAM FROM NON-TRIBAL SUPPLIERS—INDIANS ARE LEFT OUT OF THE PROCESS
METRO SPIRIT 2007
(“Bison in a Can,” August 4, http://www.metrospirit.com/index.php?ShowArticle_ID=11013107074654929&cat=1211101074307265)
3. SCENARIO ONE—HUNGER
FAILURE OF STATUS QUO FOOD PROGRAMS CAUSES BOTH DISPROPORTIONATE HUNGER AND OBESITY AMONG NATIVE AMERICANS—THE RESULT IS A RANGE OF HEALTH PROBLEMS LIKE MALNUTRITION, DIABETES, AND HEART DISEASE
NEWPORT 2007
(Melinda, MS,RD/LD Director Nutrition Services for Chickasaw Nation, Hearing before the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee, Jan 31, http://agriculture.senate.gov/Hearings/hearings.cfm?hearingid=2511&witnessId=6032)
4. WE MUST CHALLENGE THE UNEVEN DISTRIBUTION OF FOOD AT ANY COST—OUTWEIGHS ANY POTENTIAL DISADVANTAGE
WATSON 77
(Richard, Professor of Philosophy at Washington University, World Hunger and Moral Obligation, p. 118-119)
5. The starvation is a denial of basic human rights.
Polly VIZARD Research Associate Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion London School of Economics 2006 Oxford University Press
6. Violations of human rights threaten survival.
Rhonda Copelon, Professor of Law and Director of the International Women's Human Rights Law Clinic at the City University of New York School of Law, New York City Law Review, 1998/99, 3 N.Y. City L. Rev. 59
7. SCENARIO TWO—CULTURE
REFUSAL TO PURCHASE BISON FROM INDIAN PRODUCERS UNDERMINES TRIBAL CULTURE—THIS ACT SPILLS OVER TO CRUSH TRIBAL AUTONOMY
LULKA 2006
(David, San Diego State University, Great Plains Research, Spring, http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1804&context=greatplainsresearch)
8. INDIAN CULTURE IS KEY TO ALL CULTURES—POLICIES IMPLEMENTED FOR INDIANS ARE MODELED THROUGHOUT SOCIETY
CHURCHILL 1997
(Ward, Professor of Ethnic Studies at University of Colorado at Boulder, A Little Matter of Genocide: Holocaust and Denial in the Americas, 1492 to the present, p. 340)
9. SURVIVAL AND RESTORATION OF TRIBAL CULTURE ARE KEY TO PREVENT HUMAN EXTINCTION—THIS IMPACT SOLVES ALL OTHERS
WEATHERFORD 1994
(Jack, Anthropologist, Savages and Civilization: Who Will Survive?, pp. 287-291)
10. SCENARIO THREE—REINTRODUCTION
CORPORATE BISON INTERESTS FIGHT FOR REGULATION INSTEAD OF EXPANDING WILD BISON HERDS—THIS WILL DESTROY BISON’S UNIQUE CULTURAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL INFLUENCES AND UNDERMINE SUPPORT FOR WILD BISON RESTORATION
LULKA 2008
(David Lulka, Dept of Geography, San Diego State University, Journal of Cultural Geography, February)
11. NOW IS THE KEY TIME TO INFLUENCE THE BISON MARKET—CHANGING POLICIES NOW CAN ALTER THE DEBATE OVER BISON RESTORATION
LULKA 2008
(David Lulka, Dept of Geography, San Diego State University, Journal of Cultural Geography, February)
12. Bison reintroduction is key to restore prairie ecosystems.
Valles Caldera National Preserve, 5/9/09, “Bison Enhanced Prairie,” Caldera Options, http://calderaoptions.com/Bison_Enhanced_Prairie.html
13. PRAIRIES ARE KEY TO OVERALL BIODIVERSITY
WWF 2005
(World Wildlife Fund, “Agriculture and Environment: Wheat,” Nov 13, http://www.panda.org/about_wwf/what_we_do/policy/agriculture_environment/commodities/wheat/environmental_impacts/habitat_conversion/index.cfm)
14.
BIODIVERSITY IS KEY TO CHECK EXTINCTION
WATSON 2006
(Captain Paul, Founder and President of Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, has a show on Animal Planet, Last Mod 9-17, http://www.eco-action.org/dt/beerswil.html)
15. PLAN: THE UNITED STATES FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SHOULD FUND THE EXPANSION OF THE FOOD DISTRIBUTION PROGRAM ON INDIAN RESERVATIONS, INCLUDING CULTURALLY APPROPRIATE FOODS PROCURED FROM INDIAN PRODUCERS USING TRADITIONAL AGRICULTURAL PRACTICES.
16. CONTENTION THREE—SOLVENCY
THE FDPIR IS CRITICAL TO DISTRIBUTE BISON TO LOCAL COMMUNITIES—THIS DISTRIBUTION IS THE KEY ELEMENT IN PRESERVING NATIVE LIFEWAYS
LULKA 2006
(David, San Diego State University, Great Plains Research, Spring, http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1804&context=greatplainsresearch)
17. CREATING DEMAND IS KEY—THIS ALLOWS TRIBES TO EXPAND THEIR HERDS
CHADWICK 2006
(Douglas, wildlife biologist, Defenders Magazine, Fall, http://www.defenders.org/newsroom/defenders_magazine/fall_2006/where_the_buffalo_now_roam.php)
18. THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS AN OBLIGATION TO PROVIDE BISON—IT SHOULD BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR PAST VIOLENCE AGAINST INDIANS
LULKA 2006
(David, San Diego State University, Great Plains Research, Spring, http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1804&context=greatplainsresearch)
19. OUR EXAMINATION OF FEDERAL BISON POLICY IS CRUCIAL TO CREATE TRANSPARENCY AND SHAPE THE DIRECTION OF DEBATES OVER BISON
LULKA 2008
(David Lulka, Dept of Geography, San Diego State University, Journal of Cultural Geography, February)
Negative
Specific Rounds
Princeton (Ohio)
Aff: STEM Education
1NC: SKFTA Politics T - Social Services Biopower Nietzsche States Case
2NC: Biopower Nietzsche
1NR: Politics Case
2NR: Biopower
Princeton (Ohio) Quarterfinals
Aff: TANF
1NC: Nietzsche Cap and Trade Politics T - Removing a Barrier XO CP Case
2NC: Nietzsche
1NR: Politics XO CP
2NR: Nietzsche
